Best Mattress Protector – Top Selections For 2017!

When it comes to getting a great night’s sleep, there are a wide variety of things that can affect whether or not you wake up feeling refreshed or groggy. One of those things can be allergies, which is exacerbated by things like having a mattress that is full of dust mites and other allergens.

On top of that, there are plenty of other things that can be lurking inside your bed, which is why it can be crucial to have a mattress protector over it. These simple yet effective products enable you to keep your mattress clean and eliminate things like bugs and allergens from your sleep.

This way you should be able to get more rest while also extending the life of your mattress. Over time, dust and bodily fluids can turn your bed into a toxic waste dump, but a protector can help alleviate that problem.

Today we’ll be looking at some of the best mattress protectors on the market as well as go over the most important considerations you should pay attention to before making a final decision. Sleep is a valuable resource, so choose wisely.

Comparison on 10 Best Mattress Protectors

10 Best Mattress Protectors in 2017 - Reviews

1. Evolon Allergy Mattress Protector

Evolon Allergy Mattress Protector

When looking at different protectors, you’ll notice that some of them are designed for a particular use. In this case, the Evolon is built to keep allergens from disturbing you while you sleep.

The way that it does that is by encasing your mattress in a thin microfilament material that will prevent dust, mites, and other undesirables from escaping.

The material itself is tightly packed yet surprisingly flexible. Some people describe it as having a “paper-like” feel to it, but the fact is that you have to wash it before putting it on. One thing that the Evolon does well is absorb (and shed) water, meaning that a wash makes it feel so much softer.

Overall, this cover is designed only for allergens, so if you are looking to keep out other pests like bed bugs, you’ll have to look elsewhere. That being said, this protector is very good at keeping dust and mites away from you while you sleep, so keep that in mind.

Also, it is made with eco-friendly processes and doesn’t include any harsh chemicals or dyes.

Pros

  • Evolon engineered material
  • Prevents allergens from spreading with a microfiber material
  • Eco-friendly construction
  • Can absorb up to four times its weight in water
  • Dries out rapidly
  • Soft, breathable fabric
  • No harsh chemicals or plastics used
  • Zippered cover to protect you from allergens and bugs
  • Safe to use with bleach, built to handle many cleanings
  • Rustle-free material won’t slip
  • Durable and lightweight

Cons

  • Must be washed before use
  • Does not fit “deep” mattresses with toppers
  • Can rip relatively easily
  • Does not protect against bed bugs

2. Protect-A-Bed Luxury Waterproof Mattress Protector

Protect-A-Bed Luxury Waterproof Mattress Protector

While products like the Evolon above are designed to keep all allergens out of your mattress, they can still be somewhat uncomfortable because they don’t breathe that well.

This means that during hot summer nights you can feel a bit roasted as your body heat reflects back to you from the cover. If you want to keep your mattress clean while also cooling yourself at night, then this protector from Protect-A-Bed could be right for you.

What makes this cover so desirable is that it is made from thermo-regulating eucalyptus fibers. This means that it dissipates heat well so that you stay cool all night long. Not only that, but it is waterproof so that sweat and other bodily fluids won’t soak into your mattress.

That being said, though, don’t expect this to hold up against bed wetting; that’s not what this is designed to do.Overall, this cover is built to keep your bed clean. The material does keep out dust mites and allergens as well, so it can also be useful for that purpose.

It goes over the mattress like a fitted sheet, making it easy to put on take off, and it gets softer as you wash it. Finally, the cover is 100% organic, making it an eco-friendly choice as well.

Pros

  • Thermo-regulating eucalyptus fibers
  • Stays cool and dissipates heat while you sleep
  • Completely waterproof to keep your mattress bone dry
  • Fabric is still breathable though to keep you cool
  • All natural and organic materials; no chemicals
  • Creates a barrier for mites and allergens
  • Fitted encasement for easier placement
  • Soft and lightweight material

Cons

  • Not zippered, meaning that it doesn’t provide 100% protection
  • Not designed to repel bed bugs
  • Must be washed before use
  • Not made for bedwetting

3. Protect-A-Bed Waterproof California King

Protect-A-Bed Waterproof California King

Next, we have another cover from Protect-A-Bed. Much like its predecessor, this mattress protector is built to keep your bed clean more than anything else, meaning that it can do a lot for your mattress over time.

The cover is designed to repel fluids like sweat and body oils so your bed can stay pristine for longer. It can also work for some nighttime accidents, but that’s not its intended purpose.

Overall, the biggest difference between this and the one above is that it is not made from organic materials. That being said, there are no harsh chemicals or anything in this cover, and you can even use it right out of the bag without having to wash it first. 

Also, there is no smell or anything either, so you can sleep soundly right away. If you’re looking for a decent way to keep your mattress from getting dirty, this can be an excellent option.

Pros

  • Breathable and waterproof fabric
  • Repels sweat and other fluids
  • Keeps dust mites and allergens at bay
  • Fitted sheet styling allows for easier placement
  • Easy to clean in the washer
  • Regulates your temperature to keep you cool
  • Absorbent so that your mattress isn’t
  • Does not need to be washed first

Cons

  • Not built for bedwetting
  • Warranty is extremely limited
  • Does not protect against bugs

4. Allersoft Dust Mite & Allergy Control

Allersoft Dust Mite & Allergy Control

So far we’ve seen protectors that are built for allergens and liquid repellant qualities, but nothing has been able to repel bed bugs. Thankfully, if that is a problem that you’d like to avoid then this protector from Allersoft will be a welcome addition to your bedroom.

Overall, this cover is designed to keep all allergens and pests from getting out of your mattress and into the air or onto your body.

It is a fully-zippered protector, so all mites and bugs will not be able to escape. So, if allergies and bugs are your primary concern, this cover does a fantastic job of that. It is not waterproof though, so keep that in mind.Being 100% cotton also means that this cover is super soft and breathable, but it can shrink after washing so plan accordingly.

Fortunately, the company replaces covers if there is ever a problem, but it’s better to know that ahead of time, so you don’t have to deal with getting a replacement. Nonetheless, this cover is perfect for allergy sufferers.

Pros

  • 100% breathable cotton material
  • Rigorously tested for performance
  • Fully zippered encasement
  • Protects against mites, allergens and bed bugs
  • Soft, comfortable and breathable
  • Easy to clean and machine washable
  • Double stitched for better durability
  • No harsh chemicals or plastics
  • Made in the USA
  • Limited lifetime warranty

Cons

  • Can take a lot of effort to wrap the cover around your mattress
  • Not waterproof
  • May shrink slightly after washing, which can affect performance depending on the size you have

5. Sleep Tite Hypoallergenic 100% Waterproof 

Sleep Tite Hypoallergenic 100% Waterproof

Next, we have another protector that slips over your current mattress to keep it clean and free from the burden of your bodily waste.

This cover from Sleep-Tite is designed to keep sweat and skin flakes from settling into your mattress while also preventing dust and mites from crawling up.

It is a fitted sheet style protector which means that it is easy to put on and take off, but it won’t keep bed bugs away. Nonetheless, if your primary goal is to keep your mattress in great shape and to reduce the number of allergens to which you’re exposed, then this is a great buy.

It has a cotton top that is soft and breathable as well as a polyurethane bottom that keeps fluids from seeping into your bed. Best of all, it’s easy to clean and doesn’t have any harsh chemicals.

Pros

  • Soft and durable cotton and plastic cover
  • Designed to be hypoallergenic and waterproof
  • Keeps mites and dust out
  • Repels liquid from seeping into the mattress
  • Breathable and comfortable
  • Fitted sheet design for easier placement and removal
  • No harsh chemicals
  • No rustling or slipping while sleeping

Cons

  • Not made for bedwetting
  • Does not provide bed bug protection
  • Not 100% effective due to encasement design
  • Can get warm while you sleep

6. Luna Mattress Protectors Queen Size Luna Premium 

Luna Mattress Protectors Queen Size Luna Premium

Next, we have a versatile and durable mattress cover from Luna. This is similar to the other ones we’ve seen, meaning that this model is designed for keeping your bed clean above all else.

The cotton terry fabric is soft against your skin and breathes well at night, keeping you from overheating. Underneath is a thin plastic membrane that will keep sweat and other bodily fluids from seeping into the mattress.

As far as allergens are concerned, the fitted sheet-style cover protects well against dust, dust mites, and other particulate that can cause allergies.

However, bed bugs can still be an issue with this protector. The whole thing is machine washable and comes off really easily, making it an excellent addition to your bedroom.

Pros

  • Soft and durable construction
  • Cotton terry top and polyurethane bottom
  • Vinyl and phthalate free
  • No harsh chemicals
  • Waterproof design
  • Fitted sheet style cover
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Keeps dust and mites away
  • Easy to clean; machine washable
  • Better airflow to keep you cool

Cons

  • Can be warm for some users
  • Not designed for bed wetting
  • Does not protect against bed bugs

7. SafeRest Queen Size SafeRest Premium 

SafeRest Queen Size SafeRest Premium Hypoallergenic

So far, we’ve seen mattress covers that can help prevent liquid from seeping into your bed, but they are not built for nighttime accidents.

However, this next model from SafeRest is much better about repelling liquid, meaning that it should be a good buy for anyone with pets or children who may soil the mattress from time to time.

It’s not quite as effective as perhaps a latex covering, but it is better than most.In addition to being excellent at liquid repellant, this cover is also soft and breathable thanks to the cotton terry towel cover.

This protector is quite good at keeping dust mites and other allergens away from you as it comes with deep pockets to cover more of the mattress on the bottom. Also, if you do decide to get it for a child, this unit is free from all harsh chemicals and dyes, making it both practical and safe.

Pros

  • Soft and comfortable cotton cover
  • Waterproof membrane to keep liquids and spills out
  • Protects against mites and allergens
  • Easy slip-on fitted sheet-style cover
  • Hypoallergenic material
  • Free from all harsh chemicals
  • Breathable and noiseless design
  • Ideal for kids or pets
  • Does not change the feeling of your mattress

Cons

  • Edges are not covered by waterproof material
  • Repeated washings may wear out the seams
  • Does not protect against bed bugs

8. SURE Premium 100% Waterproof Mattress Protector

SURE Premium 100% Waterproof Mattress Protector

Next, we have another cover that can hold up to more damage than most of the other ones we’ve seen. In fact, we have to say that, compared to most other protectors, this one from SURE has the best liquid repelling action.

That means that, while it’s not exactly built for bed wetting, it can handle most accidents without causing any problems.

This is made all the better by the fact that it is still a fitted sheet model, meaning that you don’t get 100% coverage. Overall, the amount of protection that you get coupled with the incredible softness and comfort makes the SURE Protector one of our favorites.

It is easy to clean and maintain, and it won’t create any rustling noise or feel weird while you sleep. Also, it’s safe for kids as it doesn’t contain any harsh chemicals or dyes.

Pros

  • Soft and breathable cotton exterior
  • Waterproof polyurethane membrane
  • Allows for airflow but blocks liquids
  • Fits over your mattress like a fitted sheet
  • Easy to clean and machine washable
  • Free from any harsh chemicals or dyes
  • Ideal for pets and kids
  • Traps allergens and keeps your mattress clean
  • Noiseless design

Cons

  • Can be warm for some users
  • Some sizes may be a little off when fitting on your mattress
  • Not designed to protect against bed bugs

9. Hanna Kay Queen Size Hanna Kay Premium 

Hanna Kay Queen Size Hanna Kay Premium

If you’re looking for a mattress cover that is simple and cost-effective, then this one from Hanna Kay could be a great buy.

It is very similar to the other ones we’ve seen, so if your primary goal is to keep your mattress clean, then it will do that job nicely. The top of the cover is made of soft cotton terry towel, and underneath is a thin polyurethane membrane.

This protector can keep sweat and body oils from seeping into your mattress, but it’s not exactly built for spills or accidents, so don’t get it for that reason.

That being said, if you swap it out quickly after a spill, you should be able to prevent anything from seeping in. Overall, this is a decent cover at a great price.

Pros

  • Soft cotton terry cloth upper
  • Thick waterproof polyurethane bottom
  • Keeps mites and allergens out
  • Prevents liquids from seeping into the mattress
  • Hypoallergenic materials
  • Breathable fabric
  • No noise or noticeable change in your mattress
  • Slips on like a fitted sheet
  • Machine washable for convenience

Cons

  • Some parts of the cover may make noise
  • Not designed for bed wetting
  • Does not protect against bed bugs

10. Lucid® LUCID Premium Hypoallergenic 

Lucid® LUCID Premium Hypoallergenic

Finishing off our list is this protector from Lucid. Like many of the other ones we’ve seen, this model is designed as kind of an “all-around” unit, meaning that it can protect against a lot of different things; something like a protector of all trades.

The material itself is a combination of cotton terry towel on the top and polyurethane on the bottom.

This helps ensure that the cover is soft and breathable while still keeping your mattress dry from sweat and body oils.

Unfortunately, this particular model does not protect against urine very well, so don’t get it if that is a concern. Overall, this is a decent cover that can extend the life of your mattress by several years.

Pros

  • Soft and breathable cotton terry outside
  • Thin waterproof membrane underneath
  • Fitted sheet design is easy to put on and take off
  • Machine washable for convenience
  • Ideal for kids and pets
  • Traps allergens and mites
  • Quiet design doesn’t feel any different than your mattress
  • Keeps your bed clean for longer

Cons

  • Waterproof membrane does not last as long as the cotton top
  • Does not keep out bed bugs
  • Can sleep hot for some users

How to Choose The Best Mattress Protector

Purpose

Before you start looking at a mattress cover, you first need to determine how you are going to use it. Are you trying to keep your bed clean, or are you worried about bed bugs? Do you want something that can be utilized for bed wetting?

These are the questions that you have to ask yourself so that you can be better prepared for finding the right cover for your needs. The top three goals of any mattress cover are:

Mattress Protector

Keep your bed clean and help it last longer Protect against allergens such as dust and mites Prevent liquids from seeping into the mattress Other kinds of mattress protectors can add comfort to your bed by containing foam or other cushioning, and some of them are made to keep out bed bugs and other pests.

Also, some thicker protectors are ideal for bed wetting and will not allow any liquid to pass through. As a general rule, unless the cover mentions it specifically, it will not hold up to repeated nighttime accidents.

Material

For the most part, mattress covers are made with two different materials; one to be soft and comfortable and the other to keep liquids from seeping through. Usually, the top is made of cotton, and the bottom is polyurethane, but some covers use a variety of materials.

Here is a brief rundown of the ones you can most commonly find.

Cotton: if the whole thing is cotton then it will not be waterproof. Look for 100% cotton if you want something soft and breathable

Polyurethane: this is the usually the membrane layer that keeps fluids from seeping into your mattress, but most covers have a thin layer that works best for sweat or spills

Organic Fibers: some protectors are more eco-friendly and use 100% organic or natural materials instead of polyurethane. If you’re environmentally conscious, look for the organic label

Latex: if bed wetting is your primary concern, then this will help keep your mattress dry. It can run a bit hot, though, so there is a tradeoff

Fastener

When choosing the best mattress protector, it’s important that you pay attention to how it fits onto your mattress. If you’re trying to keep pests like bed bugs from infesting your bed, then you will want something with a zipper so that they can’t get in or out.

Zippered covers are usually made to repel allergens and pests more than anything, but they are generally not completely waterproof. The alternative is to get an elastic protector that goes over your mattress like a fitted sheet.

These are easier to take on and off, but they don’t prevent bed bugs, and they might not be ideal for liquids. However, this type of fastener is the most common, so if you do go this route then be sure to get one that has deep pockets. This will ensure that you get enough coverage on the bottom and that it won’t come off easily.

Final Verdict

Considering that many of these covers have a lot of the same features, it can be tough to decide which one is the best. However, we have narrowed it down to our top three picks, which are the Protect-A-Bed Luxury model, the Allersoft Protector, and the Sure Premium Protector.

We like the Luxury cover because it keeps you cool and is environmentally friendly. We like the Allersoft because it can prevent bed bugs from staking a claim on your bed and it is the best to combat allergies. Finally, the Sure Premium Cover is best at keeping your mattress clean, and it can even hold up to bed wetting, so it’s our favorite all-around choice.

Relevant Resources:

Willie D. Jones
 

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments