Best Crib Mattress Options 2017 – Top 5 Compared

One of the biggest challenges that new parents face is how to let their babies sleep. While some prefer to co-sleep in the same bed, a lot of parents choose to have their kids sleep in a crib. Although there is some debate about which is better, there is one thing that you want most, and that is for your child to be as comfortable as possible.

Thus, if you do have your little one sleep in a crib, you need a high-quality mattress to make every night a breeze.So, with that in mind, let’s take a look at some of the best crib mattresses on the market today.

Each one of these is built to be as accommodating and comfortable for your baby as possible, so don’t fret about whether or not he or she will get a good night’s sleep. Overall, the important thing is to make sure that the size and material are right for your child.

 

10 Best Crib Mattresses - Quick Comparisons

Image

Sheet Name

Material

Dimensions (inches)

Price

Newton Crib Mattress

Newton Crib Mattress

100% Peruvian Pima Cotton

15 x 12 x 4

Naturepedic No Compromise Organic

Naturepedic No Compromise Organic

100% Cotton

14.5 x 9.5 x 4.5

Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer

Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer

100% Cotton

14 x 10 x 3

Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness

Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness

100% Cotton Percale

102 x 90 x 0.2

LA Baby 2 in 1 Crib Mattress

LA Baby 2 in 1 Crib Mattress

100% Cotton Percale

15.2 x 10.4 x 3.6

Best Crib Mattresses in 2017 -  Review

1. Newton Crib Mattress

Newton Crib Mattress

When looking at various mattresses for your little one’s crib, many offer a dual-stage system for sleeping. The way it works is that one side is more firm than the other so that it’s better for infants.

This is one such mattress, and it works incredibly. Newton has always made high-quality materials, and this product is a testament to that fact.

What we like most about this mattress is that it is 100% breathable. Babies love to sleep on their stomachs, so if they shift throughout the night, they won’t have any problem breathing through this fabric. In fact, the mattress is 90% air, meaning that it’s also incredibly soft. That, coupled with the two-sided material means that you can use this bed for years as it will grow and adapt with your baby.

The other thing we like about this product is that it’s both washable and recyclable. Babies always have bedtime accidents, so when that happens you can toss the whole thing into the wash, and it will be perfectly clean for the next night. Also, because it doesn’t have any harsh chemicals, springs, or glues, you can recycle it when the time comes to upgrade your child to a standard bed.

Pros

  • Naturally breathable design, baby can lay face down with no problems
  • Plush with ventilated airflow to reduce sweating and overheating
  • Washable and free from all harsh chemicals
  • No springs or glues included in the mattress
  • Dual-stage material for infants and toddlers
  • 100% recyclable
  • 90% air so that it feels like sleeping on a cloud
  • Weighs only 11 pounds
  • Mattress cover included
  • Made in the USA

Cons

  • In rare cases, the material may irritate baby’s skin
  • Some children may not like the feel of the fabric

2. Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Mattress

Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Mattress

Next, we have another two-stage crib mattress that will grow with your baby all the way into toddlerhood. What’s important to note about this model is that, although it says 100% organic cotton material, there are still metal coils inside, so it’s not completely natural.

That being said, everything that touches your baby’s skin is soft and natural, which is a fantastic feature.

One of the best selling points of this mattress is that it comes with an organic cotton cover that is also waterproof. While it won’t prevent nighttime accidents from seeping in, it will help you keep the mattress clean by repelling most liquids and making it easy to wipe them up.

Overall, if you catch an accident right away then the interior should stay dry, but if it has time to soak, then it will break through the waterproof barrier. Still, having it is much better than nothing, especially because it helps prevent mold and mildew from setting in. Sweat and other bodily oils can turn a mattress into an unsanitary place, but this covering helps you keep it cleaner for longer.

Pros

  • 100% organic cotton material
  • Dual firmness for infants and toddlers
  • Waterproof surface to repel stains
  • Waterproof seams prevent mold and mildew inside
  • Firm and comfortable coils inside for support
  • Edges are supported as well to eliminate sagging
  • Surface is food-grade for health and safety
  • GreenGuard certified for environmental health
  • Weighs 20 pounds
  • Made in the US

Cons

  • Waterproof surface is not suited for repeated bedwetting
  • Coils may be uncomfortable for some babies
  • Over time, coils will start to lose stiffness

3. Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Firmness

Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Firmness

One popular material that is used for many crib mattresses is thick polyurethane foam. This is similar to memory foam, although it’s treated to make sure that it doesn’t have any harsh odors or chemicals inside.

The benefit of using this material is that it hugs your little one’s body to relieve pressure points and deliver a fantastic night’s sleep.

In this case, the foam is also double sided so that one side is extra firm for infants and the other is standard firmness for toddlers. The other thing that we like about this mattress is that it has a waterproof and hypoallergenic cover.

Again, like the Moonlight Slumber above, it’s not designed to keep the bed dry when your little one has an accident, but it does make cleaning a lot easier, and it helps prevent mold from setting in. Also, since the foam is hypoallergenic, you don’t have to worry about dust or mites causing problems with your baby.

Pros

  • Dual-thickness foam
  • Firm on one side, soft on the other
  • Free of harsh chemicals
  • CertiPUR certified
  • Waterproof and hypoallergenic cover
  • Wipes clean with a damp cloth
  • GreenGuard certified for environmental safety
  • Edge support
  • Fireproof material
  • Weighs only ten pounds

Cons

  • In some cases, the foam may start to sag over time
  • Not designed to repel bedwetting accidents
  • May run a bit shorter than advertised

4. Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness

Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness

In today’s modern world, it’s more important than ever to be environmentally friendly. Unfortunately, mattresses are notoriously hard to break down and use up a lot of man-made materials to get made.

Thankfully, this model from Colgate is designed to be as eco-friendly as possible while still being made of high-quality foam.

While it’s not as good as something that is 100% organic, it’s still much better than most of the other mattresses out there. As far as comfort and performance go, this unit is pretty standard. It has two sides; one that’s extra firm and one that’s a bit softer. This allows you to use the same mattress for your child as he or she grows from infant to toddler.

What we like most is that it comes with an organic cotton cover so that your little one has a softer and safer sleep experience. Overall, this mattress is certified to both be free of any harsh chemicals as well as be environmentally safe, so you can buy it with peace of mind.

Pros

  • Dual firmness lightweight foam
  • 100% organic cotton covering
  • GreenGuard certified for environmental safety
  • CertiPUR certified to be free of all harsh chemicals
  • Cover has waterproof backing to make cleaning a snap
  • Eco-friendly materials
  • Weighs less than ten pounds

Cons

  • In rare cases, the mattress may arrive damaged
  • Cover may run a bit hot while sleeping
  • Mattress itself is not organic

5. LA Baby 2 in 1 Crib Mattress

LA Baby 2 in 1 Crib Mattress

While foam is a fantastic material for most crib mattresses, the fact is that it can compress over time and leave large dips where your baby sleeps. Flipping it over can help somewhat, but once it loses its firmness, then it’s not coming back.

So, if you want to give your child the best support possible, this mattress from LA Baby might be a better option.

One thing to note about this product is that it’s not completely organic or environmentally certified, so if that is a dealbreaker for you, then you might want to move on. That being said, the cover has two layers of organic cotton so that your baby isn’t exposed to any harsh chemicals or odors.

What we like most about this mattress is that it provides excellent support that will last for years. It’s another dual-sided model (one for infant, one for a toddler), so you can flip it over when your child wants something a bit softer. Plus, the covering is hypoallergenic and has a waterproof backing to help prevent mites and mold from creeping in. Overall, it’s an excellent mattress if support is your biggest concern.

Pros

  • Durable coil spring mattress
  • Dual sided to grow with your baby
  • Two layers of organic cotton covering for comfort
  • 15.5 gauge steel coils provide excellent support
  • Border rods included to prevent sagging on the sides
  • Hypoallergenic covering
  • Dust mite proof mattress
  • Weighs eighteen pounds
  • Made in the USA

Cons

  • In rare cases, the mattress may have a harsh odor upon arrival
  • In some instances, the coils may create lumps in the mattress
  • Not entirely organic

6. Serta Tranquility Eco Firm Mattress

Serta Tranquility Eco Firm Mattress

If you like the idea of having a firm, supportive mattress like the LA Baby above, but you want something that is a bit better on the environment, then this model from Serta can be a better option.

Like the LA Baby, it comes with a ton of coils to make the mattress as firm as possible, but it also has a CertiPUR and GreenGuard certification, meaning that it is rated to not have any harsh chemicals and be better for the environment.

What we like most about this mattress (besides the support) is the fact that it comes with thick organic layers of cotton so that your baby gets soft comfort while he or she sleeps. The covering is also waterproof to prevent against nighttime leaks, and the whole thing is ventilated to improve airflow. Overall, this is one of the best coil crib mattresses you can find.

Pros

  • Foam and coil mattress
  • Dual-sided for infants and toddlers
  • 120 coils for extra support
  • CertiPUR certified to be free of all harsh chemicals
  • GreenGuard certified for environmental safety
  • Organic material covering
  • Waterproof layers to prevent leaks
  • Ventilated to keep it cool and dry
  • Weighs sixteen pounds

Cons

  • Not designed for heavy bedwetting
  • In rare cases, the coils may create a lumpy, uneven surface

7. Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Infant/Toddler

Sealy Soybean Foam-Core InfantToddler

For most foam mattresses, they use man-made chemicals like polyurethane to create the foam material.

In this case, however, Sealy uses soy products to make the foam, meaning that it is much more eco-friendly and safe for your child. That’s not to say that the others are unsafe, but that this is a better option.

What’s so great about this soy foam is that it is high density. That means that it will maintain its shape for much longer than most other similar mattresses, and it won’t start to sag in the middle.

Also, like the other ones that we’ve seen, this is a dual-stage model that works both for infants and toddlers alike. Overall, if you want something more natural for your baby, this is an excellent choice.

Pros

  • High-density soy foam mattress
  • Dual stage for infants and toddlers
  • Organic covers and materials
  • Waterproof for easy cleaning
  • CertiPUR certified as free of all harsh chemicals
  • Stain-resistant cover
  • Hypoallergenic and prevents mites from getting inside
  • GreenGuard certified for air quality and environmental safety
  • Weighs only eight pounds
  • Made in the USA

Cons

  • Corners may sag
  • In rare instances, the outer layer may rip
  • In some cases, the foam may start to sink over time

8. BeautySleep SlumberTime Naturally Mattress

BeautySleep SlumberTime Naturally Mattress

Next, we have another soy filled mattress, but this one is from BeautySleep. Much like the one above, this model is designed to be both high-density and all-natural, meaning that you get the best of both worlds.

Best of all, it’s both CertiPUR and GreenGuard certified, so you know that it’s free of chemicals and better for the environments.

The other thing that we like about this mattress is that it comes with a natural woven cotton cover. Not only is this cover softer and more comfortable for your child, but it has a waterproof backing to make cleaning even easier and help prevent mold and mildew from setting in. Finally, this is another dual-stage mattress that will grow with your baby as he or she gets older.

Pros

  • Dual stage mattress for infants and toddlers
  • High-density soy foam interior
  • GreenGuard certified for air quality and safety
  • CertiPUR certified as free of all harsh chemicals
  • Natural woven cotton cover
  • Weighs ten pounds
  • Waterproof backing for easier cleaning
  • Made in the USA

Cons

  • May be too firm initially for some children
  • In rare cases, the mattress may have a strong odor upon arrival

9. My First Premium Memory Foam Hypoallergenic

My First Premium Memory Foam Hypoallergenic

So far we’ve seen plenty of beds that are dual-sided so that it works well for both infants and toddlers. However, this next model is designed specifically for babies, meaning that it is extra firm and extra comfortable.

That does mean that you will have to get a separate model for your toddler when the time comes, but it also means that your baby will sleep incredibly well.

The secret to this mattress is that it is made entirely of memory foam. However, there is no reason to worry as it is also CertiPUR certified, so it’s also free of all harsh chemicals. Nonetheless, the fact that it is memory foam means that your baby will get a better night’s sleep, and it’s completely washable and waterproof.

Not only that, but it’s naturally hypoallergenic and antimicrobial, which makes the whole thing even better. Overall, if you want your baby to sleep soundly, this is the mattress to get.

Pros

  • Thick memory foam mattress
  • Washable and waterproof material
  • CertiPUR certified to be free of all harsh chemicals
  • Hypoallergenic and mold-resistant
  • Anti-microbial to prevent bacteria from growing
  • Uses gel and base foam for extra support and comfort

Cons

  • Will take several days to take shape
  • In rare cases, it may have a strong odor upon arrival
  • In some instances, the edges may sag

10. Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress

Our final mattress is a thick and lightweight model from Safety 1st. It has a high-density thermo-bonded core that provides excellent support for your little one all night long, but it also only weighs 7.5 pounds, making it one of the lightest mattresses we’ve seen.

If you’re looking for something simple and easy to clean, then this will be a great buy.

The other thing that we like about this mattress is that it has a waterproof vinyl covering that can help protect the insides from bedwetting accidents. This is probably the best mattress out of all of the ones we’ve seen for that purpose. Also, it still has the CertiPUR and GreenGuard certifications, making it a great product all around.

Pros

  • High-density thermo-bonded core
  • Provides thick support for your baby
  • Adjusts to your child’s growth
  • Waterproof vinyl cover
  • CertiPUR certified to be free of harsh chemicals
  • GreenGuard certified for air quality and environmental safety
  • Weighs only 7.5 pounds
  • Hypoallergenic covering
  • Made in the USA

Cons

  • Size may run a bit shorter than advertised
  • In rare cases, the mattress may start to break down over time
  • In rare instances, it may have a strong odor upon arrival

How to Choose a Crib Mattress

Size

First and foremost, when picking out a mattress for your little one’s crib, you have to make sure that it will fit. While there is technically a “standard” size for crib mattresses, the fact is that there can still be a lot of variance among brands.

As such, it’s imperative that you pay attention to the dimensions of the product before buying. If it’s too small, then it could pose a risk as your baby can get stuck between the mattress and the crib. It can also be a suffocation hazard, so that’s why it’s so critical.

The other thing to consider is how thick and heavy the mattress is. You want it to be thick enough to provide ample support, but not so thick that it will allow your baby to crawl out of the crib. Also, weight can be an issue if you have to take it out regularly for cleaning, so keep that in mind. Most mattresses are around ten pounds, but those with coils can be much heavier.

Material

This factor is just as important as the dimensions as it will affect your baby’s overall comfort. There are several primary materials used in mattresses, which are foam, cotton, and coils. Foam mattresses are great because they offer softer support for your baby, but they can sink over time and have a harsh odor.

Cotton mattresses are better if you are concerned about being all-natural, but they can get dirty quite easily. Finally, coil-filled models provide the most support, but they can’t be washed (just wiped down) and they are not environmentally friendly. These are all things to consider when deciding the right material for your child.

Organic vs. Synthetic

These days, there is a growing demand for mattresses that are 100% natural. The reason being that it will be safer for the child and be better for the environment. What’s important to note here is that if the whole thing is organic, then the price will be much higher. In many cases, mattresses will have an organic covering, which can alleviate some problems. Overall, it’s up to you whether this distinction is worth it or not.

Dual Stage

As we’ve seen, most crib mattresses have two sides to them. One side is extra firm to provide ample support for infants, while the other is designed for toddlers. What’s important to remember, though, is that the side does matter. You may think that they are pretty much the same, but there is a critical difference.

Infants need extra support for proper muscle and skeleton development, as well as to prevent suffocation hazards. Toddlers, on the other hand, need a softer bed so that they can sleep easier at night. The benefit of getting a double-sided model is that you can use it for longer, rather than getting an infant mattress and a toddler one later.

Final Verdict

After looking through these mattresses, we have to say that our top pick was the very first one that we showcased. The Newton Crib Mattress is our best choice because it has the comfort and features that your baby deserves. We love that it’s all natural and filled with mostly air, and we also love that it is 100% breathable and washable. When it comes to safety and ease of use, this mattress is the gold standard.

See More Products Review

Willie D. Jones
 

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments